Home > Media Centre > Press Releases Printer-friendly page  

18 February 2004 

 

PRESS STATEMENT BY MINISTRY OF EDUCATION ON KENT RIDGE SECONDARY SCHOOL STUDENTS FOUND WITH PORNOGRAPHIC VCDS

 

Introduction

1.             There has been considerable public and media interest over the incident involving students of Kent Ridge Secondary School who were found by the school to have possessed and viewed pornographic VCDs. The school had issued statements in response to media queries. As these have not fully clarified the issues, the Ministry would like to set out the facts, in particular regarding the school's decision to report the incident to the Police and its handling of its students during investigations, and the Ministry's position on the matter.

The Incident

2.             On Wed 4 Feb 04, a teacher found a pornographic VCD on a Sec 2 student.

3.             On Thu 5 Feb 04 the school sought to inform his parents about the matter but was unable to get through because their phone was on fax mode.

4.             On Fri 6 Feb 04, another student was found to be involved. He confessed to having a pornographic VCD at home. The school managed to contact the mother of this student. The school also managed to contact the father of the first student. The father, who was on the road, said that he would return the call but he did not do so. By the end of the day, the school discovered that there were a total of 17 students involved.

5.             On Mon 9 Feb 04, the school conducted further investigations on all 17 students from 8.05 a.m. As part of the investigations, the students were asked to write statements of their involvement in the matter in the school's designated detention area. When the Principal found some of the students sitting in the sun at around 11 am, she asked them to move to a shadier area away from the sun. Based on the information gathered from the school's investigations, the Principal decided to report the matter to the Police. Parents were also informed that the school was reporting the matter to the Police.

6.             Three students were brought to the Police Station for questioning. All three were subsequently released, with one of the students being released on bail.

Why the School Decided to Call in the Police

7.             Possession of pornographic materials is an offence under the law. The students' statements indicated to the school that the problem was more extensive than initially thought. They had in their possession various pornographic VCDs and had been watching them over a period of time in different homes. The school could not ascertain the source of these pornographic VCDs as there were conflicting accounts on the source from the students' statements.

8.             The school decided to call in the Police as it was concerned that the problem might be more widespread than it appeared, and the source was not clear. The school was concerned not only with the 17 students in question but also the rest of the student community in the school. The Principal judged that it was necessary to call in the Police to help determine the extent of the problem and the source of the VCDs. MOE supports the decision of the Principal, who had to make a judgement based on her assessment of the situation at hand.

The Handling of School's Investigations

9.             Schools endeavour to inform parents on matters concerning indiscipline among students. However, schools are not required to inform or consult parents in advance of taking action, including making a police report. Where the school does not inform the parents before a police report is made, it will do so after the report has been made. In the present case, the school did seek to contact the parents of the two students at the centre of the issue as its investigations progressed, and contacted the rest of the parents after it had called the police.

10.           However, MOE is of the view that the school should have handled the incident better in several respects. The school should have allowed the students involved to have their meal breaks during the school's investigations over several hours on 9 February. The staff had responded inappropriately to the students' requests for a break to obtain food and drinks. The school should also have been aware of the need for food and water by the student with Hirshsprung disease, as his parent had previously informed the school of the matter. The Principal has acknowledged these mistakes and apologised to the parents concerned for this. The school should also have explained the situation to the parents more effectively, upon calling them to the school on 9 February.

School Will Continue to Counsel Students

11.           Schools, parents and the community have to work together in helping our young imbibe the right values and attitudes and to minimise their exposure to undesirable influences. Schools recognise that students in secondary schools are at an age when they are susceptible to many influences, and some may be tempted to explore pornographic materials. Schools go through considerable effort to address this, including educating and counselling their students, and where necessary disciplining them.

12.           MOE would like to make clear however that where there are disciplinary problems in a school, the Principal has discretion on the actions to be taken. These include counseling the students and disciplining them within the school, which is the course of action taken for most offences. However, depending on the severity of the offence and the willingness of the students involved to cooperate, Principals will sometimes call in the Police. Schools should not be disparaged for doing so, particularly where there is evidence of illegal activity. The Police will decide in such situations if any further action is required. Even when a police report is made, however, schools will continue to counsel the students involved.

13.           All the 17 Kent Ridge Secondary students in question are back in school and have resumed normal lessons. The school is counselling them. MOE will also ensure that the school reviews its internal processes with a view to improving the management of such situations, and will share the lessons learnt with other schools.

 


 
 

Page Last Updated : 13-Jul-2004

This site is best viewed with IE ver 5.x and Netscape ver 7.x
Copyright 2004 Ministry of Education. All rights reserved.
Privacy Statement | Terms of Use